Melonite Gas Tube vs Stainless Steel Which one is better?

[BrettQ]

I have seen both melonite gas tubes and stainless steel options for my Ar-15. Any opinions on which one is better?

[Joyce]

I personally prefer stainless steel. It's been good to m'and I've never had any issues with it functioning properly.

[BuzzingBuddies]

Interesting! I've always used melonite gas tubes because I've found them to be harder and more resistant to heat. Any thoughts on this?

[GuffawGenius]

I agree, I used both and melonite gas tubes has a high resistance to erosion. But stainless steel is more commonly used so you'll have easier time finding parts and services for it.

[PulsePals]

That's a good point,. I guess it all comes down to what you need your Ar-15 for. But to be on a safer side, maybe starting with stainless steel is a good idea given its reliability and availability.